Don’t Settle for Less: How to Challenge Low Home Appraisals When Selling to Cash Buyers

Pezon Properties • January 19, 2024

Not all homes must be appraised. For cash buyers, you can opt out. This often occurs when home prices are up, and inventory is low. However, if you are financing your new home, you will have to get an appraisal. Most housing experts agree, as well, that if you are paying for your house in cash, it’s still a good idea to know its worth.  (1)


A low appraisal may compromise a buyer’s finances and derail the sale of your house. It could also make it difficult to renew your mortgage or obtain funds through a cash-out refinance home equity loan. An appraisal may come back lower than expected due to a reduction in property prices or because you underestimated the market value of your home. However, the appraisal process is not without flaws, and there are recourse alternatives if you believe the appraiser made a mistake or you suspect assessment discrimination. 


Here’s what to do if your house appraises for less than you expect.

sell my house fast Lancaster

Examine the Appraisal Report for Preciseness

The lender sends the loan applicant a complimentary copy of the appraisal report at least three days before the loan closes. You’ll get one if you’re applying for a home equity loan. However, in the case of a home sale to we buy houses Lancaster companies, the buyer will obtain it as part of the mortgage procedure. If you are the seller, consult with your agent to obtain a copy of the buyer’s report. 


The appraisal report contains a deluge of property facts that the appraiser took into account when valuing the property. Even the finest appraisers sometimes make mistakes, so go over the report carefully to ensure that all of the details are accurate, such as:


  • The total number of bedrooms and bathrooms.
  • Measurement in square feet.
  • Amenities like fireplaces, patios, and swimming pools.
  • The type and condition of the garage.
  • Roof, furnace, and other main systems included in the report.
  • Additional features including energy-saving systems.

Request a Value Appeal from your Lender

If you discover mistakes in the home appraisal, the next step is to contact your lender and request an appeal. This is a very crucial step that must not be overlooked. It is difficult to persuade lenders to revise their assessment, although it is not unheard of. If you want to pull this off, you’ll need to do some research. 



You must back up any claims you make with evidence when requesting a value appeal.

Highlight Upgrades and Improvements to the Appraiser

A home appraiser is only in your home for a brief period, and he may overlook changes or renovations you made that increase the worth of your property. Just because you are aware of the renovations in your home doesn’t mean the appraisers are. Consider speaking to the appraiser about these modifications or renovations in an educational rather than contemptuous manner. Remember, this is a people business. 

Don’t cross any boundaries regarding appraisers, but develop a working rapport with them. 

Ensure That No Permits Are Missing

You may have a value issue if you make extensions or renovations to your home without obtaining building permits. An appraiser cannot incorporate the renovations in your home’s evaluation if they are not permitted. If you did obtain permits but the appraiser cannot locate them, go to your county or city government office to see if they can be found. Keep detailed records for such inconsistencies.

Examine the Comps

Appraisers evaluate the prices of comparable homes that have recently sold in the area, known as real estate comps, to assist in assessing your home’s value before you sell my house fast Lancaster. Examine the properties that were used. Were they, in fact, comparable? How close are the houses, and how recently did they sell? 


If you’re working with one, you may request a list of recent comparable sales from a friendly agent familiar with your neighborhood or your agent.

Send in a ‘Reconsideration of Value’ Form

Document any errors or missing information from the appraisal report as soon as possible and any additional information about similar transactions that you believe should be considered. If you are the loan applicant, then provide that written material to your lender as part of a “reconsideration of value.” If you are the house seller, request that your real estate agent explain these issues to the buyer and that the buyer report this information to their lender. Although the loan applicant pays the appraiser, the appraiser actually works for the lender. 



As a result, any feedback on the appraisal should be directed to the lender rather than the appraiser. The information will be forwarded to the appraiser by the lender. The additional details you supply may encourage the appraiser to adjust the appraisal, but only if they are relevant and significant enough to move the needle. A loan applicant may also request a second appraisal or begin the process with a different lender. 

However, appraisals often cost several hundred dollars, and there is no guarantee that the next evaluation will be greater.

If You Suspect Discrimination, File a Complaint 

Home appraisers are not allowed to discriminate based on someone’s skin color, religion, sex, disability, family status, or national origin under the 1968 Fair Housing Act. Nonetheless, numerous media reports in recent years have highlighted cases where properties were valued higher when Black homeowners concealed proof of their race. Even though the stories were fresh, the concept of “white-washing” a home to get a fair price has a long and traumatic history in the Black community. If you believe a lender discriminated against you, including by relying on an unfair assessment, you can file a complaint. 

A fair housing complaint is another possibility. You can contact the Urban Development Office directly or seek assistance from your local fair housing center. Fair housing centers conduct preliminary investigations and assist people with the complaint process. On the HUD website, you can locate a fair housing organization near you.


Remember that if you sell your home to we buy houses Reading organizations, you don’t need to deal with the complexities of an appraisal.

Give us a call anytime at 484-484-0971 or fill out this quick form to get started today!

Get A Fair Cash Offer On Your House

Mathew Pezon

About the author

Mathew Pezon

Mathew Pezon is the founder and CEO of Pezon Properties, a cash home buying company located in Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania. With several years of experience in the real estate industry, Mathew has become a specialist in helping homeowners sell their properties quickly and efficiently. He takes pride in providing a hassle-free, transparent, and fair home buying experience to his clients. Mathew is also an active member of his local community and is passionate about giving back. Through his company, he has contributed to various charities and causes.

Selling a House With Asbestos
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Selling a house with asbestos? Learn legal requirements, disclosure rules, and tips to sell safely and profitably. Get expert insights now!
Can Someone Sell a House if Your Name Is on the Deed
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Find out if someone can sell a house when your name is on the deed. Learn your legal rights and how to protect your ownership.
Tax Implications of Selling a House in a Trust After Death
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Discover the tax implications of selling a house in a trust after death, including capital gains, exemptions, and key legal considerations.
Selling a House With Mold
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Selling a house with mold? Learn your options, legal requirements & how to attract buyers while minimizing risks. Get expert tips to sell fast!
Do I Need a Lawyer If I Sell My House for Cash
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Selling your house for cash? Find out if you need a lawyer, the legal risks, and how to ensure a smooth transaction. Read more now!
Do You Have to Pay Capital Gains When You Sell Your House
By Mathew Pezon March 30, 2025
Wondering if you need to pay capital gains tax when selling your house? Learn the rules, exemptions, and how to reduce your tax burden.
Can I Sell a House I’m Paying for on Land Contract
By Mathew Pezon March 5, 2025
Yes, you can sell a house on a land contract, but restrictions may apply. Learn your options, legal considerations, and steps to sell successfully.
Can I Sell My House If I Have a Home Equity Loan
By Mathew Pezon March 5, 2025
Yes, you can sell your house with a home equity loan. Learn how it affects your sale, what to expect, and key steps to close the deal smoothly.
Can a Judge Force You to Sell Your House in a Divorce
By Mathew Pezon March 5, 2025
Can a judge force you to sell your house in a divorce? Learn when courts can order a sale, your rights, and legal options to protect your property.
Can I Sell My House to My LLC and Rent It Back
By Mathew Pezon March 4, 2025
Wondering if you can sell your house to your LLC and rent it back? Learn the legal, tax, and financial implications before making a decision.
More Posts